Supply chain β›“ Supply Chain

Google / Fragomen Del Rey Bernsen & Loewy Law Firm Breach (October 2020)

πŸ“… 2020-09-24 🏒 Fragomen, Del Rey, Bernsen & Loewy
Primary Source β†—

Incident Details

Fragomen, Del Rey, Bernsen & Loewy LLP β€” one of the largest immigration law firms in the United States, with over 582 attorneys across 47 global offices β€” disclosed a data breach affecting current and former employees of its client Google. On September 24, 2020, an unauthorized third party gained access to the firm’s network and accessed a file containing personal information of Google employees who had used the firm’s I-9 employment eligibility verification services.

Fragomen provides immigration law and employment verification services to major technology companies and other large employers. As part of I-9 processing, the firm collects and retains detailed personal documentation verifying workers’ legal authorization to work in the United States. The accessed file contained: full legal names, dates of birth, home addresses, email addresses, phone numbers, Social Security numbers, passport details, and other immigration-related identifiers from I-9 and visa processing.

The breach was publicly disclosed on October 26, 2020 β€” approximately one month after the intrusion. Fragomen declined to specify the number of affected individuals, describing it only as “a discrete number of Googlers” and former Google employees. The intrusion method was not detailed beyond being characterized as unauthorized access. Google was notified, and Fragomen offered complimentary identity theft protection and credit monitoring services to all affected individuals.

This incident is a textbook third-party supply chain breach: Google itself was not directly compromised, but its employees’ sensitive PII was exposed through a vendor entrusted with HR and immigration compliance functions. Immigration law firms are particularly high-value targets because I-9 and visa files routinely contain passport scans, Social Security numbers, and government-issued identification β€” some of the most valuable PII for identity fraud purposes.

The number of affected individuals was never publicly disclosed by either Fragomen or Google, making this one of the more opaque high-profile third-party breaches of 2020. The incident highlighted the security risks inherent in legal service providers handling sensitive HR and immigration data, a class of vendor that had historically received less security scrutiny than direct technology suppliers.

Technical Details

Initial Attack Vector
Unauthorized third-party network intrusion into law firm; single file with I-9 employment verification records accessed
Vendor / Product
Fragomen, Del Rey, Bernsen & Loewy
Supply Chain Attack
βœ… Confirmed third-party / vendor compromise

Timeline

  1. 2020-09-24 Breach occurred
  2. 2020-10-26 Publicly disclosed